Okay bestie, AI just hit the stock market in a big way, and there’s drama — let’s talk about it.
So Anthropic (the company behind Claude) just had its IPO, and the stock popped 17% on day one, closing at $97.17. Huge. But here’s the twist: right as it went public, critics started pointing at falling token prices as evidence the whole AI trade might be cooling off. Should you be worried if you’re eyeing this stock — or is it just noise? Let’s break it down, because this is exactly the kind of thing I walk my coaching clients through: look past the scary headline, understand the actual business, then decide.
First, what even is a “token”?
Quick refresher, because I refuse to let finance jargon intimidate you. Tokens are basically the units of AI — little chunks of text that models like Claude process when you chat with them. Every time you use AI, tokens are being bought and sold behind the scenes, and companies like Anthropic make money on that usage. Think of it like paying for data by the gigabyte. If the price per gigabyte drops, does that mean the phone company is doomed? Not necessarily — and we’ll get to why.
Why the bears are buzzing
Here’s the argument making the rounds: Bloomberg’s chief economist, Anna Wong, posted that the effective price per million tokens has dropped sharply lately — while Anthropic’s token usage share didn’t rise, and even edged down a bit. Her take? Anthropic looks like an oligopolist without durable pricing power, meaning growth depends on cutting prices to drive volume. And that, friends, is a tough business model.
The numbers back up the price part, at least. The usage-weighted Silicon Data LLM Token Expenditure Index — which tracks prices per million tokens — fell more than 40% between late June and early October, and prices kept dropping after that. Anthropic even cut prices by 20% on its newest frontier model, Fable 5.2.
So why are prices falling? Three big reasons:
- Competition from cheaper models is pushing prices down across the industry.
- Customers are shifting habits, using cheaper models for routine tasks and saving the fancy (expensive) models for the hard stuff.
- Costs are falling too — more efficient computing means Anthropic can lower prices without necessarily crushing its own profits.
Here’s what I’d tell you: reason #3 is the one people skip over, and it matters a lot. Falling prices because you’re getting cheaper to operate is very different from falling prices because you’re losing a price war.
The Anthropic situation is… wild
Let’s be honest, this stock has one of the widest ranges of possible outcomes ever. On the bullish side, the company has identified a $40 trillion market opportunity, and CEO Dario Amodei believes the tech could cure diseases like cancer and Alzheimer’s within a decade. Goldman Sachs projects $440 billion in revenue by 2029, and Morningstar’s bull case puts the share price at $188.
On the other end of the spectrum? One of the company’s own researchers said there’s more than a 10% chance it “could kill all humans.” I’m not going to lie — that sentence stopped me mid-latte. That is the risk spectrum we’re dealing with here, from world-saving to world-ending. This is why I tell my coaching clients: high-upside stocks deserve position sizes you can emotionally and financially afford.
And then there’s the distillation issue. Distillation is when other companies train their AI models using an existing model’s outputs instead of doing expensive original research — basically the AI version of counterfeiting. Amodei has called for a crackdown on industrial-scale distillation, arguing it undercuts the massive R&D investments market leaders make and discourages innovation long-term. He also flags it as a national security concern, since it lets China build far better models than it otherwise could. Cheaper knockoffs = more price pressure on the real thing.
Okay, but is falling revenue-per-token actually fatal?
Here’s where the bears might be overthinking it. Yes, lower prices look bad on the surface — less revenue per unit. But there’s a concept called the Jevons paradox: when something gets cheaper, people use way more of it. Lower prices can actually drive increased usage and grow the pie over time. (Same reason streaming got enormous once it got cheap.)
And so far, Anthropic is proving the pessimists wrong in at least two ways. The company posted 47% sequential growth in the third quarter — meaning it grew right through the price declines. Even better, it’s scaling revenue faster than its computing costs and has reached an adjusted operating profit. A company cutting prices while still growing profits? That’s not necessarily a red flag. That might just be a smart strategy.
The comparison that changed my perspective
This is my favorite part of the whole story, because it’s a lesson in how technology investing actually works. In tech, prices almost always fall over time — competition improves, efficiency improves, and companies pass savings along.
Case in point: Amazon invented cloud computing and is still the market leader, even though it has cut prices hundreds of times over the years due to economies of scale, competitive pressure, and keeping customers loyal to its platform. Despite all that price-cutting, AWS kept growing and became one of the most valuable businesses in the world — even on a standalone basis. Cutting prices didn’t kill the leader. It helped cement the lead.
Anthropic shares a lot of DNA with early AWS: a leader in a brand-new technology, with a massive addressable market ahead of it. Pricing is one piece of the puzzle — not the whole puzzle. If demand for AI is anywhere near as big as it could be, and Anthropic keeps growing profits, falling token prices are a business detail worth monitoring, not a five-alarm fire.
My honest take
This is why I tell my coaching clients to never judge a stock by one metric making headlines. Token prices falling? Noted. But also: 47% quarterly growth, positive adjusted operating profit, and a market opportunity measured in trillions. The bears aren’t wrong that competition and distillation are real risks — they absolutely are, and this stock is not for your emergency fund, period. But “prices are falling” alone isn’t the smoking gun some are making it out to be.
If you want to play in AI, you don’t have to bet on one company either. Sometimes the smartest move is a diversified fund that gives you exposure to the whole theme while limiting the “one stock goes sideways” risk. Diversification isn’t boring — it’s how you stay in the game long enough to win.
Here’s what I’d do if I were you: add this to your watchlist, keep an eye on whether Anthropic’s revenue and profits keep growing alongside those price cuts, and make sure any AI investment fits inside a portfolio you’ve actually planned out — not one built on IPO-day hype.
If you want help building a portfolio that lets you chase exciting opportunities without wrecking your financial foundation, come join my mailing list or DM me your biggest investing question — let’s get you investing smarter, babe. 💛
