AAPL351.91-0.87 (-0.25%) ▼|ABBV292.82-1.73 (-0.59%) ▼|ABT104.71-2.74 (-2.55%) ▼|ACN239.28-8.42 (-3.40%) ▼|ADBE235.55-10.45 (-4.25%) ▼|AMAT349.23-1.02 (-0.29%) ▼|AMD503.41-0.87 (-0.17%) ▼|AMGN457.93-4.39 (-0.95%) ▼|AMT183.18-7.56 (-3.96%) ▼|AMZN257.89+0.14 (+0.05%) ▲|AVGO341.60+8.20 (+2.46%) ▲|AXP315.78-3.27 (-1.02%) ▼|BA163.91-1.31 (-0.79%) ▼|BAC49.44-0.64 (-1.28%) ▼|BKNG154.46-3.07 (-1.95%) ▼|BLK1,180.67-17.30 (-1.44%) ▼|BMY61.35-1.58 (-2.51%) ▼|BNY149.79-1.90 (-1.25%) ▼|BRK-B586.76-6.09 (-1.03%) ▼|C119.94-1.38 (-1.14%) ▼|CAT570.79+0.30 (+0.05%) ▲|CL99.61-1.38 (-1.37%) ▼|CMCSA25.31-0.29 (-1.13%) ▼|COF186.78-6.44 (-3.33%) ▼|COP139.48-1.04 (-0.74%) ▼|COST1,110.08-3.66 (-0.33%) ▼|CRM194.52-20.31 (-9.45%) ▼|CSCO95.11+0.59 (+0.62%) ▲|CVS85.81-2.78 (-3.14%) ▼|CVX216.13-1.01 (-0.47%) ▼|DE649.23-4.76 (-0.73%) ▼|DHR225.77-4.14 (-1.80%) ▼|DIS116.94-1.76 (-1.48%) ▼|DUK129.84-0.75 (-0.57%) ▼|EMR159.15-1.50 (-0.93%) ▼|FDX319.94-7.71 (-2.35%) ▼|GD355.63-4.06 (-1.13%) ▼|GE326.40+1.22 (+0.38%) ▲|GEV779.91+16.34 (+2.14%) ▲|GILD170.26+2.68 (+1.60%) ▲|GM84.05+0.38 (+0.45%) ▲|GOOG277.60-3.66 (-1.30%) ▼|GOOGL280.20-3.52 (-1.24%) ▼|GS877.52-14.02 (-1.57%) ▼|HD339.01-8.50 (-2.45%) ▼|HON218.96+1.01 (+0.46%) ▲|IBM231.09-11.42 (-4.71%) ▼|INTC55.17-0.27 (-0.49%) ▼|INTU320.79-24.77 (-7.17%) ▼|ISRG430.53-7.22 (-1.65%) ▼|JNJ278.70-3.85 (-1.36%) ▼|JPM329.96-8.25 (-2.44%) ▼|KO98.79-0.69 (-0.69%) ▼|LIN515.11-8.35 (-1.60%) ▼|LLY1,415.55-16.12 (-1.13%) ▼|LMT590.34+5.13 (+0.88%) ▲|LOW220.46-4.47 (-1.99%) ▼|LRCX210.69-0.14 (-0.07%) ▼|MA645.73-15.98 (-2.42%) ▼|MCD275.82+1.15 (+0.42%) ▲|MDLZ66.75-0.79 (-1.17%) ▼|MDT102.32-0.56 (-0.54%) ▼|META618.87-7.54 (-1.20%) ▼|MMM180.88-0.80 (-0.44%) ▼|MO77.46-1.44 (-1.83%) ▼|MRK143.37-1.09 (-0.75%) ▼|MS183.53-2.04 (-1.10%) ▼|MSFT506.24-11.75 (-2.27%) ▼|MU712.42-6.60 (-0.92%) ▼|NEE84.42-0.92 (-1.08%) ▼|NFLX59.68-1.07 (-1.76%) ▼|NKE35.85-2.41 (-6.30%) ▼|NOW92.90-6.47 (-6.51%) ▼|NVDA155.46-0.68 (-0.44%) ▼|ORCL115.00-4.09 (-3.43%) ▼|PEP142.02-4.41 (-3.01%) ▼|PFE28.47-0.39 (-1.35%) ▼|PG171.72-1.30 (-0.75%) ▼|PLTR156.56-3.83 (-2.39%) ▼|PM194.38-1.66 (-0.85%) ▼|QCOM166.67-1.85 (-1.10%) ▼|RTX198.00+3.11 (+1.60%) ▲|SBUX107.49-1.23 (-1.13%) ▼|SCHW91.84-1.10 (-1.18%) ▼|SO93.60-1.04 (-1.10%) ▼|SPG230.24-2.54 (-1.09%) ▼|T22.29-0.07 (-0.31%) ▼|TMO686.79-4.54 (-0.66%) ▼|TMUS167.90-2.11 (-1.24%) ▼|TSLA380.11+0.37 (+0.10%) ▲|TXN295.86+1.65 (+0.56%) ▲|UBER68.81-1.18 (-1.69%) ▼|UNH389.68-22.34 (-5.42%) ▼|UNP297.03-6.68 (-2.20%) ▼|UPS110.31-1.51 (-1.35%) ▼|USB59.18-1.25 (-2.07%) ▼|V416.77-9.69 (-2.27%) ▼|VZ45.93-0.41 (-0.88%) ▼|WFC82.69-2.15 (-2.53%) ▼|WMT127.52-0.89 (-0.69%) ▼|XOM167.21+0.34 (+0.20%) ▲|AAPL351.91-0.87 (-0.25%) ▼|ABBV292.82-1.73 (-0.59%) ▼|ABT104.71-2.74 (-2.55%) ▼|ACN239.28-8.42 (-3.40%) ▼|ADBE235.55-10.45 (-4.25%) ▼|AMAT349.23-1.02 (-0.29%) ▼|AMD503.41-0.87 (-0.17%) ▼|AMGN457.93-4.39 (-0.95%) ▼|AMT183.18-7.56 (-3.96%) ▼|AMZN257.89+0.14 (+0.05%) ▲|AVGO341.60+8.20 (+2.46%) ▲|AXP315.78-3.27 (-1.02%) ▼|BA163.91-1.31 (-0.79%) ▼|BAC49.44-0.64 (-1.28%) ▼|BKNG154.46-3.07 (-1.95%) ▼|BLK1,180.67-17.30 (-1.44%) ▼|BMY61.35-1.58 (-2.51%) ▼|BNY149.79-1.90 (-1.25%) ▼|BRK-B586.76-6.09 (-1.03%) ▼|C119.94-1.38 (-1.14%) ▼|CAT570.79+0.30 (+0.05%) ▲|CL99.61-1.38 (-1.37%) ▼|CMCSA25.31-0.29 (-1.13%) ▼|COF186.78-6.44 (-3.33%) ▼|COP139.48-1.04 (-0.74%) ▼|COST1,110.08-3.66 (-0.33%) ▼|CRM194.52-20.31 (-9.45%) ▼|CSCO95.11+0.59 (+0.62%) ▲|CVS85.81-2.78 (-3.14%) ▼|CVX216.13-1.01 (-0.47%) ▼|DE649.23-4.76 (-0.73%) ▼|DHR225.77-4.14 (-1.80%) ▼|DIS116.94-1.76 (-1.48%) ▼|DUK129.84-0.75 (-0.57%) ▼|EMR159.15-1.50 (-0.93%) ▼|FDX319.94-7.71 (-2.35%) ▼|GD355.63-4.06 (-1.13%) ▼|GE326.40+1.22 (+0.38%) ▲|GEV779.91+16.34 (+2.14%) ▲|GILD170.26+2.68 (+1.60%) ▲|GM84.05+0.38 (+0.45%) ▲|GOOG277.60-3.66 (-1.30%) ▼|GOOGL280.20-3.52 (-1.24%) ▼|GS877.52-14.02 (-1.57%) ▼|HD339.01-8.50 (-2.45%) ▼|HON218.96+1.01 (+0.46%) ▲|IBM231.09-11.42 (-4.71%) ▼|INTC55.17-0.27 (-0.49%) ▼|INTU320.79-24.77 (-7.17%) ▼|ISRG430.53-7.22 (-1.65%) ▼|JNJ278.70-3.85 (-1.36%) ▼|JPM329.96-8.25 (-2.44%) ▼|KO98.79-0.69 (-0.69%) ▼|LIN515.11-8.35 (-1.60%) ▼|LLY1,415.55-16.12 (-1.13%) ▼|LMT590.34+5.13 (+0.88%) ▲|LOW220.46-4.47 (-1.99%) ▼|LRCX210.69-0.14 (-0.07%) ▼|MA645.73-15.98 (-2.42%) ▼|MCD275.82+1.15 (+0.42%) ▲|MDLZ66.75-0.79 (-1.17%) ▼|MDT102.32-0.56 (-0.54%) ▼|META618.87-7.54 (-1.20%) ▼|MMM180.88-0.80 (-0.44%) ▼|MO77.46-1.44 (-1.83%) ▼|MRK143.37-1.09 (-0.75%) ▼|MS183.53-2.04 (-1.10%) ▼|MSFT506.24-11.75 (-2.27%) ▼|MU712.42-6.60 (-0.92%) ▼|NEE84.42-0.92 (-1.08%) ▼|NFLX59.68-1.07 (-1.76%) ▼|NKE35.85-2.41 (-6.30%) ▼|NOW92.90-6.47 (-6.51%) ▼|NVDA155.46-0.68 (-0.44%) ▼|ORCL115.00-4.09 (-3.43%) ▼|PEP142.02-4.41 (-3.01%) ▼|PFE28.47-0.39 (-1.35%) ▼|PG171.72-1.30 (-0.75%) ▼|PLTR156.56-3.83 (-2.39%) ▼|PM194.38-1.66 (-0.85%) ▼|QCOM166.67-1.85 (-1.10%) ▼|RTX198.00+3.11 (+1.60%) ▲|SBUX107.49-1.23 (-1.13%) ▼|SCHW91.84-1.10 (-1.18%) ▼|SO93.60-1.04 (-1.10%) ▼|SPG230.24-2.54 (-1.09%) ▼|T22.29-0.07 (-0.31%) ▼|TMO686.79-4.54 (-0.66%) ▼|TMUS167.90-2.11 (-1.24%) ▼|TSLA380.11+0.37 (+0.10%) ▲|TXN295.86+1.65 (+0.56%) ▲|UBER68.81-1.18 (-1.69%) ▼|UNH389.68-22.34 (-5.42%) ▼|UNP297.03-6.68 (-2.20%) ▼|UPS110.31-1.51 (-1.35%) ▼|USB59.18-1.25 (-2.07%) ▼|V416.77-9.69 (-2.27%) ▼|VZ45.93-0.41 (-0.88%) ▼|WFC82.69-2.15 (-2.53%) ▼|WMT127.52-0.89 (-0.69%) ▼|XOM167.21+0.34 (+0.20%) ▲|
9.9 C
New York
Wednesday, November 18, 2026
NewsEconomyTrump Tells Chip CEO to Fight for His Job—Meritocracy, Apparently

Trump Tells Chip CEO to Fight for His Job—Meritocracy, Apparently

Gina Raimondo misses nothing more than Jensen Huang’s company — not because she admires his GPUs, but because she spent four years deciding, chip by chip, exactly which ones the Chinese were allowed to buy. Speaking at Semafor’s Silicon Valley & The World conference, the former commerce secretary delivered what was framed as a withering critique of the current approach to semiconductor export controls: that the Trump administration has lurched between banning sales, permitting them, and — the kicker — taking a cut of the proceeds. In her telling, national security is binary. You’re either for it or you’re not, and it doesn’t come with a price tag.

It’s a stirring line. It’s also, if we’re being honest with ourselves, mostly theater.

Let’s reconstruct the record without the sentimentality. The Biden administration, with Raimondo at Commerce, pioneered the modern architecture of chip controls — the October 2022 rules, the successive tightening, the licensing regime that turned Nvidia’s China business into a compliance department’s full-time obsession. Huang, by his own frequent and increasingly theatrical complaints, spent years shuttling to Washington, expressing displeasure at rules that carved up his largest pre-restriction market. Raimondo acknowledges this — she spent “a lot of time” with him, and he wasn’t always happy. That is the honest part of her remarks. Everything else is the familiar claptrap of outgoing officials discovering principles the moment their signatures leave the documents.

Because here’s the inconvenient truth: the Biden framework, for all its seriousness of purpose, was itself a moving target. Export thresholds were recalibrated repeatedly. Nvidia was permitted to sell the A800 and H800 — degraded versions engineered specifically to thread the regulatory needle — then those were banned too. The policy was not a straight line; it was an arms race between Commerce’s rule-writers and Nvidia’s product engineers, with Taiwanese fab schedules caught in between. To now describe that era as one of “clearly defined” rules is to mistake administrative complexity for strategic clarity. The rules were clear only in the sense that a tax code is clear.

The Trump administration’s approach, by contrast, is more garish but more honest about what’s actually happening. The reported arrangement — allowing certain Nvidia chip sales to China in exchange for a percentage of the revenue — is ugly. It converts a security policy into a revenue-sharing scheme, which does raise the legitimate question Raimondo poses: is the goal containment or monetization? A 25 percent (or 15 percent, depending on the week) take suggests the answer is “both, and mostly the second one when the fiscal math gets uncomfortable.”

But let’s not pretend the previous approach was free of commercial considerations. The entire export control regime has always balanced three objectives that cannot be fully reconciled: slowing Chinese military modernization, preserving the revenue of American semiconductor champions, and maintaining allied cohesion. Nvidia’s China revenue funded the R&D that keeps it generations ahead. Every restriction imposed had a real cost to that flywheel — which is precisely why Huang was in Washington constantly, and why the rules kept getting softened in the details. Security policy “at a price” wasn’t invented in 2025. It’s been the operating model since the first license was granted to sell a lobotomized Hopper to a Chinese cloud provider.

The macro stakes are real, whatever one thinks of the messaging. China accounted for roughly a fifth of global AI accelerator demand before the controls, and Beijing’s response — indigenous GPU development, stockpiling, Huawei’s Ascend ramp — is the textbook consequence of any embargo in economic history. Blockade breeds substitution. The British learned this with enfilade conventions and naval stores in the eighteenth century; the Americans relearned it with rare earths. Every year the controls tighten, the marginal Chinese buyer moves closer to a domestic supplier that Washington cannot switch off. The controls may have bought time — the consensus estimate among serious analysts is a two-to-three-year lag, not a permanent wall — but they have also underwritten the capex of the very competitor they were meant to strangle.

And there’s a fiscal dimension the “security has no price” crowd prefers not to discuss. Export controls are a subsidy by another name: they redirect demand to approved buyers, they raise the value of exempted product lines, and in this new arrangement they deposit revenue directly into the Treasury. Raimondo frames the revenue share as a moral lapse. An alternative framing — less flattering to either administration — is that the entire policy has always been a negotiation between national security bureaucrats and one of the most valuable companies on earth, and the current administration has simply made the transaction explicit. Corruption and clarity are not mutually exclusive.

What should trouble sophisticated observers isn’t the oscillation itself — policy oscillation is what you get when two legitimate objectives collide — but the incentive structure it creates. When the rules change quarterly and enforcement depends on the fiscal calendar, companies plan for volatility, not compliance. Nvidia hedges,China stockpiles, allies hedge their own supply chains, and the effective constraint loosens with each reversal. Predictable severity beats erratic mercy. This is a point Raimondo could have made, and the fact that she reached for the moral formulation instead tells you she’s writing for the 2028 primary audience, not the semiconductor one.

The media coverage, naturally, has reduced all of this to a personality contest: Biden-era official scolds Trump-era pragmatism. That’s easier than explaining threshold revisions to the SM90 architecture. But the substance matters more than the soundbite. The question isn’t whether national security should have a price — it always has, and pretending otherwise is how nations end up with policies they can’t afford. The question is who sets the price and whether the buyer understands what they’ve purchased. A licensing regime that slowly strangles a market at least has the virtue of putting the price in terms Beijing can read. A revenue share reads like a protection racket with better branding.

Huang, for his part, has made his position elegantly clear: half the world’s AI researchers are Chinese, and excluding them from American silicon doesn’t make them disappear — it makes them someone else’s customers. He is commercially self-interested, obviously. He is also not wrong. The historical record on technology embargoes — from CoCom to the satellite export controls of the 1990s that gifted the launch market to Europe and China — is a record of American firms losing markets without gaining security.

Raimondo’s four years produced real achievements: coordinated controls with the Dutch and Japanese, a chokehold on lithography, genuine friction in China’s AI buildout. She deserves credit for that architecture even as she embellishes its clarity. But the critique she’s now selling — that her successors degraded principle into commerce — flatters a record that was always a bargain between security and Silicon Valley’s revenue stream. The price tag was there all along. The current administration just moved it to the front of the invoice.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Captcha verification failed!
CAPTCHA user score failed. Please contact us!

Recent News