AAPL351.91-0.87 (-0.25%) ▼|ABBV292.82-1.73 (-0.59%) ▼|ABT104.71-2.74 (-2.55%) ▼|ACN239.28-8.42 (-3.40%) ▼|ADBE235.55-10.45 (-4.25%) ▼|AMAT349.23-1.02 (-0.29%) ▼|AMD503.41-0.87 (-0.17%) ▼|AMGN457.93-4.39 (-0.95%) ▼|AMT183.18-7.56 (-3.96%) ▼|AMZN257.89+0.14 (+0.05%) ▲|AVGO341.60+8.20 (+2.46%) ▲|AXP315.78-3.27 (-1.02%) ▼|BA163.91-1.31 (-0.79%) ▼|BAC49.44-0.64 (-1.28%) ▼|BKNG154.46-3.07 (-1.95%) ▼|BLK1,180.67-17.30 (-1.44%) ▼|BMY61.35-1.58 (-2.51%) ▼|BNY149.79-1.90 (-1.25%) ▼|BRK-B586.76-6.09 (-1.03%) ▼|C119.94-1.38 (-1.14%) ▼|CAT570.79+0.30 (+0.05%) ▲|CL99.61-1.38 (-1.37%) ▼|CMCSA25.31-0.29 (-1.13%) ▼|COF186.78-6.44 (-3.33%) ▼|COP139.48-1.04 (-0.74%) ▼|COST1,110.08-3.66 (-0.33%) ▼|CRM194.52-20.31 (-9.45%) ▼|CSCO95.11+0.59 (+0.62%) ▲|CVS85.81-2.78 (-3.14%) ▼|CVX216.13-1.01 (-0.47%) ▼|DE649.23-4.76 (-0.73%) ▼|DHR225.77-4.14 (-1.80%) ▼|DIS116.94-1.76 (-1.48%) ▼|DUK129.84-0.75 (-0.57%) ▼|EMR159.15-1.50 (-0.93%) ▼|FDX319.94-7.71 (-2.35%) ▼|GD355.63-4.06 (-1.13%) ▼|GE326.40+1.22 (+0.38%) ▲|GEV779.91+16.34 (+2.14%) ▲|GILD170.26+2.68 (+1.60%) ▲|GM84.05+0.38 (+0.45%) ▲|GOOG277.60-3.66 (-1.30%) ▼|GOOGL280.20-3.52 (-1.24%) ▼|GS877.52-14.02 (-1.57%) ▼|HD339.01-8.50 (-2.45%) ▼|HON218.96+1.01 (+0.46%) ▲|IBM231.09-11.42 (-4.71%) ▼|INTC55.17-0.27 (-0.49%) ▼|INTU320.79-24.77 (-7.17%) ▼|ISRG430.53-7.22 (-1.65%) ▼|JNJ278.70-3.85 (-1.36%) ▼|JPM329.96-8.25 (-2.44%) ▼|KO98.79-0.69 (-0.69%) ▼|LIN515.11-8.35 (-1.60%) ▼|LLY1,415.55-16.12 (-1.13%) ▼|LMT590.34+5.13 (+0.88%) ▲|LOW220.46-4.47 (-1.99%) ▼|LRCX210.69-0.14 (-0.07%) ▼|MA645.73-15.98 (-2.42%) ▼|MCD275.82+1.15 (+0.42%) ▲|MDLZ66.75-0.79 (-1.17%) ▼|MDT102.32-0.56 (-0.54%) ▼|META618.87-7.54 (-1.20%) ▼|MMM180.88-0.80 (-0.44%) ▼|MO77.46-1.44 (-1.83%) ▼|MRK143.37-1.09 (-0.75%) ▼|MS183.53-2.04 (-1.10%) ▼|MSFT506.24-11.75 (-2.27%) ▼|MU712.42-6.60 (-0.92%) ▼|NEE84.42-0.92 (-1.08%) ▼|NFLX59.68-1.07 (-1.76%) ▼|NKE35.85-2.41 (-6.30%) ▼|NOW92.90-6.47 (-6.51%) ▼|NVDA155.46-0.68 (-0.44%) ▼|ORCL115.00-4.09 (-3.43%) ▼|PEP142.02-4.41 (-3.01%) ▼|PFE28.47-0.39 (-1.35%) ▼|PG171.72-1.30 (-0.75%) ▼|PLTR156.56-3.83 (-2.39%) ▼|PM194.38-1.66 (-0.85%) ▼|QCOM166.67-1.85 (-1.10%) ▼|RTX198.00+3.11 (+1.60%) ▲|SBUX107.49-1.23 (-1.13%) ▼|SCHW91.84-1.10 (-1.18%) ▼|SO93.60-1.04 (-1.10%) ▼|SPG230.24-2.54 (-1.09%) ▼|T22.29-0.07 (-0.31%) ▼|TMO686.79-4.54 (-0.66%) ▼|TMUS167.90-2.11 (-1.24%) ▼|TSLA380.11+0.37 (+0.10%) ▲|TXN295.86+1.65 (+0.56%) ▲|UBER68.81-1.18 (-1.69%) ▼|UNH389.68-22.34 (-5.42%) ▼|UNP297.03-6.68 (-2.20%) ▼|UPS110.31-1.51 (-1.35%) ▼|USB59.18-1.25 (-2.07%) ▼|V416.77-9.69 (-2.27%) ▼|VZ45.93-0.41 (-0.88%) ▼|WFC82.69-2.15 (-2.53%) ▼|WMT127.52-0.89 (-0.69%) ▼|XOM167.21+0.34 (+0.20%) ▲|AAPL351.91-0.87 (-0.25%) ▼|ABBV292.82-1.73 (-0.59%) ▼|ABT104.71-2.74 (-2.55%) ▼|ACN239.28-8.42 (-3.40%) ▼|ADBE235.55-10.45 (-4.25%) ▼|AMAT349.23-1.02 (-0.29%) ▼|AMD503.41-0.87 (-0.17%) ▼|AMGN457.93-4.39 (-0.95%) ▼|AMT183.18-7.56 (-3.96%) ▼|AMZN257.89+0.14 (+0.05%) ▲|AVGO341.60+8.20 (+2.46%) ▲|AXP315.78-3.27 (-1.02%) ▼|BA163.91-1.31 (-0.79%) ▼|BAC49.44-0.64 (-1.28%) ▼|BKNG154.46-3.07 (-1.95%) ▼|BLK1,180.67-17.30 (-1.44%) ▼|BMY61.35-1.58 (-2.51%) ▼|BNY149.79-1.90 (-1.25%) ▼|BRK-B586.76-6.09 (-1.03%) ▼|C119.94-1.38 (-1.14%) ▼|CAT570.79+0.30 (+0.05%) ▲|CL99.61-1.38 (-1.37%) ▼|CMCSA25.31-0.29 (-1.13%) ▼|COF186.78-6.44 (-3.33%) ▼|COP139.48-1.04 (-0.74%) ▼|COST1,110.08-3.66 (-0.33%) ▼|CRM194.52-20.31 (-9.45%) ▼|CSCO95.11+0.59 (+0.62%) ▲|CVS85.81-2.78 (-3.14%) ▼|CVX216.13-1.01 (-0.47%) ▼|DE649.23-4.76 (-0.73%) ▼|DHR225.77-4.14 (-1.80%) ▼|DIS116.94-1.76 (-1.48%) ▼|DUK129.84-0.75 (-0.57%) ▼|EMR159.15-1.50 (-0.93%) ▼|FDX319.94-7.71 (-2.35%) ▼|GD355.63-4.06 (-1.13%) ▼|GE326.40+1.22 (+0.38%) ▲|GEV779.91+16.34 (+2.14%) ▲|GILD170.26+2.68 (+1.60%) ▲|GM84.05+0.38 (+0.45%) ▲|GOOG277.60-3.66 (-1.30%) ▼|GOOGL280.20-3.52 (-1.24%) ▼|GS877.52-14.02 (-1.57%) ▼|HD339.01-8.50 (-2.45%) ▼|HON218.96+1.01 (+0.46%) ▲|IBM231.09-11.42 (-4.71%) ▼|INTC55.17-0.27 (-0.49%) ▼|INTU320.79-24.77 (-7.17%) ▼|ISRG430.53-7.22 (-1.65%) ▼|JNJ278.70-3.85 (-1.36%) ▼|JPM329.96-8.25 (-2.44%) ▼|KO98.79-0.69 (-0.69%) ▼|LIN515.11-8.35 (-1.60%) ▼|LLY1,415.55-16.12 (-1.13%) ▼|LMT590.34+5.13 (+0.88%) ▲|LOW220.46-4.47 (-1.99%) ▼|LRCX210.69-0.14 (-0.07%) ▼|MA645.73-15.98 (-2.42%) ▼|MCD275.82+1.15 (+0.42%) ▲|MDLZ66.75-0.79 (-1.17%) ▼|MDT102.32-0.56 (-0.54%) ▼|META618.87-7.54 (-1.20%) ▼|MMM180.88-0.80 (-0.44%) ▼|MO77.46-1.44 (-1.83%) ▼|MRK143.37-1.09 (-0.75%) ▼|MS183.53-2.04 (-1.10%) ▼|MSFT506.24-11.75 (-2.27%) ▼|MU712.42-6.60 (-0.92%) ▼|NEE84.42-0.92 (-1.08%) ▼|NFLX59.68-1.07 (-1.76%) ▼|NKE35.85-2.41 (-6.30%) ▼|NOW92.90-6.47 (-6.51%) ▼|NVDA155.46-0.68 (-0.44%) ▼|ORCL115.00-4.09 (-3.43%) ▼|PEP142.02-4.41 (-3.01%) ▼|PFE28.47-0.39 (-1.35%) ▼|PG171.72-1.30 (-0.75%) ▼|PLTR156.56-3.83 (-2.39%) ▼|PM194.38-1.66 (-0.85%) ▼|QCOM166.67-1.85 (-1.10%) ▼|RTX198.00+3.11 (+1.60%) ▲|SBUX107.49-1.23 (-1.13%) ▼|SCHW91.84-1.10 (-1.18%) ▼|SO93.60-1.04 (-1.10%) ▼|SPG230.24-2.54 (-1.09%) ▼|T22.29-0.07 (-0.31%) ▼|TMO686.79-4.54 (-0.66%) ▼|TMUS167.90-2.11 (-1.24%) ▼|TSLA380.11+0.37 (+0.10%) ▲|TXN295.86+1.65 (+0.56%) ▲|UBER68.81-1.18 (-1.69%) ▼|UNH389.68-22.34 (-5.42%) ▼|UNP297.03-6.68 (-2.20%) ▼|UPS110.31-1.51 (-1.35%) ▼|USB59.18-1.25 (-2.07%) ▼|V416.77-9.69 (-2.27%) ▼|VZ45.93-0.41 (-0.88%) ▼|WFC82.69-2.15 (-2.53%) ▼|WMT127.52-0.89 (-0.69%) ▼|XOM167.21+0.34 (+0.20%) ▲|
11.4 C
New York
Wednesday, November 18, 2026
NewsNvidia Gets a Hug From Washington—Nothing Screams 'No Special Treatment' Louder

Nvidia Gets a Hug From Washington—Nothing Screams ‘No Special Treatment’ Louder

Raimondo Discovers that National Security Has a Price Tag, and It’s 25 Percent

Gina Raimondo wants you to know that Jensen Huang was frequently unhappy in her presence, which — for a commerce secretary whose primary job was telling one of the world’s most valuable companies what it couldn’t sell — is arguably the system working as designed. Speaking at Semafor’s Silicon Valley & The World conference, the former Biden commerce secretary drew a sharp line between her tenure and the current one: the Biden administration put national security first and drew unambiguous boundaries around what Nvidia and its fellow chip merchants could ship to China. The Trump administration, in her telling, has been oscillating among preventing sales, permitting sales, and — the novel contribution to export control doctrine — taking a 25 percent cut of sales.

Her punchline was tidy: “You’re either for America’s national security or you’re not — it’s not at a price.”

Tidy, and a bit rich.

Let’s be clear about what actually happened here, because the current arrangement — Washington licensing Nvidia’s downgraded H20 chips to China while clipping a revenue percentage for the government — is genuinely unprecedented. Export controls were historically a blunt instrument: you restricted dual-use technology because letting adversaries have it was a strategic risk, full stop. The idea that the Commerce Department should function as a licensing authority that also collects a vig, like a casino boss skimming the table, is a categorically different thing. It converts a security policy into a revenue program, and revenue programs have a nasty habit of developing constituencies. Once the Treasury is booking income from semiconductor sales to a strategic rival, every future restriction becomes a budget line item someone must argue against. Congratulations, we’ve invented an incentive to sell.

That said, Raimondo’s high dudgeon deserves scrutiny, because the previous administration’s record on these controls was hardly the pristine wall of principle being described from the stage. The October 2022 export controls were, on paper, the most sweeping technology restrictions in decades. In practice, they leaked like a Washington bartender. Nvidia engineered the H800 and A800 specifically to thread the regulatory needle — legally, enthusiastically, with an army of compliance lawyers — and the Commerce Department spent the following year playing whack-a-mole, closing loopholes roughly twelve months after Nvidia had already monetized them. Huawei, the supposed target of a total technology strangulation, recently shipped chips and phones built around domestic silicon that the controls were meant to prevent from ever existing. Smuggled chips flow into China today despite everything. The distinction between “clearly defined national security policy” and “clearly defined policy that our adversaries routed around while we congratulated ourselves” is worth more than a conference panel.

None of this is to say the licensing-for-a-cut scheme is good policy. It isn’t. The 25 percent arrangement raises an uncomfortable question that nobody in either administration has answered convincingly: what, precisely, is the security theory of the case? Either advanced AI compute in Chinese hands is an existential military risk — the stated rationale for the entire control regime — or it is a product you can sell for a handsome government markup. You cannot have it both ways, and yet we are now formally attempting both ways, which tells you the security rationale has become negotiable at exactly the moment its enforcement became expensive.

There is a historical echo here that should trouble anyone paying attention. The management of strategic technology trade with rivals has a long, unglamorous pedigree — CoCom during the Cold War being the most instructive. CoCom worked, to the extent it worked, because it was boring, rigid, multilateral, and thoroughly indifferent to the financial preferences of the companies being restricted. American semiconductor firms howled about lost Japanese and European competition during CoCom’s heyday, and Washington let them howl. Nobody contemplated monetizing the exceptions because monetization corrupts the exception. The moment revenue attaches to a license, the license-granter develops an appetite. Ask anyone who has studied how sanctions regimes decay: the enforcement mechanism with a revenue stream attached is always, eventually, the enforcement mechanism that gets quietly liberalized.

And yet — and this is where the contrarian in me must note the mainstream media’s favorite genre of story — the villain in the current narrative is being cast as uniquely transactional, when the underlying economic logic was arguably always heading here. Silicon Valley’s calculus has been constant: China represents roughly a quarter to a third of semiconductor revenue, and shareholders do not accept “national security” as a write-down category. Huang’s lobbying, the endless warnings about ceding the Chinese market to domestic champions like Huawei, the carefully timed warnings that export controls would accelerate Chinese self-sufficiency — all of that pressure was real, was bipartisan in its recipients, and was pointed toward exactly this outcome. The 25 percent cut is not an aberration from the lobbying; it is the lobbying’s terminal destination. A percentage-of-revenue model is precisely what an industry campaign for “market access” looks like once it passes through a transactional administration. Raimondo absorbed the same lobbying. Her administration simply declined the percentage and kept the restrictions — until the restrictions eroded under commercial and allied pressure anyway.

The deeper irony is that the chip war’s actual strategic scoreboard remains stubbornly unchanged by any of this administrative drama. China’s semiconductor self-sufficiency push — the Big Fund, SMIC’s scaling efforts, Huawei’s Ascend ecosystem — was accelerated, not deterred, by four years of controls. Nvidia’s China revenue has been substantially lost regardless, as Beijing has actively discouraged domestic firms from buying American chips it can no longer reliably obtain. So the United States has managed to simultaneously accelerate its adversary’s indigenization effort and forfeit the revenue from the market being indigenized. The 25 percent cut is now a percentage of a shrinking pie, collected by an arrangement that legitimizes the principle of selling. Strategically, this is the arms-dealer’s dilemma: you fund yourself by arming the party you’re containing.

What neither party will say out loud is that the export control regime was always partly theater — a demonstration of resolve, a domestic political asset, a way of appearing to do something decisive about China while the actual decisive factors, TSMC’s geography and ASML’s monopoly and the physics of lithography, sat outside American jurisdiction entirely. The Biden version of the theater was sterner and more dignified. The Trump version at least has the virtue of honesty: it prices the product and takes its cut. Neither version, however, has slowed Chinese AI development by the intervals its architects promised, and neither version has kept Washington’s semiconductor giants from structuring their entire corporate strategy around regulatory arbitrage.

Raimondo is right that national security shouldn’t have a price. But someone should have told her that the moment the United States decided that its most strategic industry should be a handful of profit-maximizing firms in a knife-fight for a Chinese market it simultaneously considered a threat, the price tag was already printed. The current administration just filled in the number.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Captcha verification failed!
CAPTCHA user score failed. Please contact us!

Recent News