AAPL349.21-3.24 (-0.92%) ▼|ABBV283.54-2.47 (-0.86%) ▼|ABT103.87-0.61 (-0.58%) ▼|ACN218.58-8.91 (-3.92%) ▼|ADBE221.68-4.52 (-2.00%) ▼|AMAT338.93-12.84 (-3.65%) ▼|AMD489.19-40.95 (-7.72%) ▼|AMGN438.82-5.07 (-1.14%) ▼|AMT181.15-3.67 (-1.99%) ▼|AMZN257.37-10.37 (-3.87%) ▼|AVGO346.65-7.40 (-2.09%) ▼|AXP311.11-4.29 (-1.36%) ▼|BA160.51-2.40 (-1.47%) ▼|BAC48.57-0.34 (-0.70%) ▼|BKNG147.32-5.96 (-3.89%) ▼|BLK1,135.81-33.40 (-2.86%) ▼|BMY58.34-1.22 (-2.05%) ▼|BNY144.83-2.97 (-2.01%) ▼|BRK-B572.04-2.58 (-0.45%) ▼|C115.28-2.06 (-1.76%) ▼|CAT537.37-21.40 (-3.83%) ▼|CL96.88-1.97 (-1.99%) ▼|CMCSA24.86-0.38 (-1.51%) ▼|COF181.76-2.54 (-1.38%) ▼|COP134.99+0.59 (+0.44%) ▲|COST1,093.83-2.79 (-0.25%) ▼|CRM183.31-7.09 (-3.72%) ▼|CSCO94.70-2.48 (-2.55%) ▼|CVS80.04-1.31 (-1.61%) ▼|CVX206.50+0.62 (+0.30%) ▲|DE624.89-19.86 (-3.08%) ▼|DHR227.56-1.02 (-0.45%) ▼|DIS120.25-2.11 (-1.72%) ▼|DUK128.86-1.19 (-0.92%) ▼|EMR157.60-4.40 (-2.72%) ▼|FDX314.64-3.67 (-1.15%) ▼|GD347.34-1.70 (-0.49%) ▼|GE318.88-9.22 (-2.81%) ▼|GEV756.28-15.94 (-2.06%) ▼|GILD166.53-2.45 (-1.45%) ▼|GM81.75-0.38 (-0.46%) ▼|GOOG271.02-8.18 (-2.93%) ▼|GOOGL272.66-9.78 (-3.46%) ▼|GS847.53-25.65 (-2.94%) ▼|HD336.68-0.96 (-0.28%) ▼|HON217.84-4.86 (-2.18%) ▼|IBM223.88-4.65 (-2.03%) ▼|INTC55.72+1.05 (+1.92%) ▲|INTU310.02-3.22 (-1.03%) ▼|ISRG407.24-13.71 (-3.26%) ▼|JNJ267.14-5.56 (-2.04%) ▼|JPM320.22-3.89 (-1.20%) ▼|KO96.09-2.00 (-2.04%) ▼|LIN510.21-1.95 (-0.38%) ▼|LLY1,351.12-31.63 (-2.29%) ▼|LMT571.85-6.34 (-1.10%) ▼|LOW219.14-3.64 (-1.63%) ▼|LRCX203.68-7.99 (-3.77%) ▼|MA626.50-16.87 (-2.62%) ▼|MCD272.35-1.68 (-0.61%) ▼|MDLZ65.69-0.88 (-1.31%) ▼|MDT100.61-0.11 (-0.11%) ▼|META596.22-20.16 (-3.27%) ▼|MMM178.47-2.58 (-1.43%) ▼|MO74.68-1.58 (-2.07%) ▼|MRK132.81-4.97 (-3.61%) ▼|MS174.98-6.19 (-3.42%) ▼|MSFT498.30-9.01 (-1.78%) ▼|MU690.44-14.83 (-2.10%) ▼|NEE83.79-0.99 (-1.17%) ▼|NFLX58.46-1.36 (-2.27%) ▼|NKE34.33-1.98 (-5.45%) ▼|NOW88.87-1.72 (-1.90%) ▼|NVDA145.98-4.98 (-3.30%) ▼|ORCL110.57-3.32 (-2.92%) ▼|PEP139.00-2.87 (-2.02%) ▼|PFE27.54-0.52 (-1.85%) ▼|PG167.85-2.44 (-1.43%) ▼|PLTR153.68-2.99 (-1.91%) ▼|PM186.43-6.30 (-3.27%) ▼|QCOM162.01+2.20 (+1.38%) ▲|RTX193.44-4.01 (-2.03%) ▼|SBUX104.47-4.64 (-4.25%) ▼|SCHW92.12-0.44 (-0.48%) ▼|SO93.29-1.12 (-1.19%) ▼|SPG225.22-6.16 (-2.66%) ▼|T21.85-0.10 (-0.46%) ▼|TMO688.75-3.99 (-0.58%) ▼|TMUS162.53-1.49 (-0.91%) ▼|TSLA374.41-9.31 (-2.43%) ▼|TXN285.75-6.68 (-2.28%) ▼|UBER65.60-3.16 (-4.60%) ▼|UNH330.48-19.43 (-5.55%) ▼|UNP290.63-10.27 (-3.41%) ▼|UPS109.11-1.92 (-1.73%) ▼|USB57.26-1.02 (-1.75%) ▼|V402.25-12.97 (-3.12%) ▼|VZ45.74-0.39 (-0.85%) ▼|WFC80.61-0.31 (-0.38%) ▼|WMT126.04-1.32 (-1.04%) ▼|XOM158.93-1.65 (-1.03%) ▼|AAPL349.21-3.24 (-0.92%) ▼|ABBV283.54-2.47 (-0.86%) ▼|ABT103.87-0.61 (-0.58%) ▼|ACN218.58-8.91 (-3.92%) ▼|ADBE221.68-4.52 (-2.00%) ▼|AMAT338.93-12.84 (-3.65%) ▼|AMD489.19-40.95 (-7.72%) ▼|AMGN438.82-5.07 (-1.14%) ▼|AMT181.15-3.67 (-1.99%) ▼|AMZN257.37-10.37 (-3.87%) ▼|AVGO346.65-7.40 (-2.09%) ▼|AXP311.11-4.29 (-1.36%) ▼|BA160.51-2.40 (-1.47%) ▼|BAC48.57-0.34 (-0.70%) ▼|BKNG147.32-5.96 (-3.89%) ▼|BLK1,135.81-33.40 (-2.86%) ▼|BMY58.34-1.22 (-2.05%) ▼|BNY144.83-2.97 (-2.01%) ▼|BRK-B572.04-2.58 (-0.45%) ▼|C115.28-2.06 (-1.76%) ▼|CAT537.37-21.40 (-3.83%) ▼|CL96.88-1.97 (-1.99%) ▼|CMCSA24.86-0.38 (-1.51%) ▼|COF181.76-2.54 (-1.38%) ▼|COP134.99+0.59 (+0.44%) ▲|COST1,093.83-2.79 (-0.25%) ▼|CRM183.31-7.09 (-3.72%) ▼|CSCO94.70-2.48 (-2.55%) ▼|CVS80.04-1.31 (-1.61%) ▼|CVX206.50+0.62 (+0.30%) ▲|DE624.89-19.86 (-3.08%) ▼|DHR227.56-1.02 (-0.45%) ▼|DIS120.25-2.11 (-1.72%) ▼|DUK128.86-1.19 (-0.92%) ▼|EMR157.60-4.40 (-2.72%) ▼|FDX314.64-3.67 (-1.15%) ▼|GD347.34-1.70 (-0.49%) ▼|GE318.88-9.22 (-2.81%) ▼|GEV756.28-15.94 (-2.06%) ▼|GILD166.53-2.45 (-1.45%) ▼|GM81.75-0.38 (-0.46%) ▼|GOOG271.02-8.18 (-2.93%) ▼|GOOGL272.66-9.78 (-3.46%) ▼|GS847.53-25.65 (-2.94%) ▼|HD336.68-0.96 (-0.28%) ▼|HON217.84-4.86 (-2.18%) ▼|IBM223.88-4.65 (-2.03%) ▼|INTC55.72+1.05 (+1.92%) ▲|INTU310.02-3.22 (-1.03%) ▼|ISRG407.24-13.71 (-3.26%) ▼|JNJ267.14-5.56 (-2.04%) ▼|JPM320.22-3.89 (-1.20%) ▼|KO96.09-2.00 (-2.04%) ▼|LIN510.21-1.95 (-0.38%) ▼|LLY1,351.12-31.63 (-2.29%) ▼|LMT571.85-6.34 (-1.10%) ▼|LOW219.14-3.64 (-1.63%) ▼|LRCX203.68-7.99 (-3.77%) ▼|MA626.50-16.87 (-2.62%) ▼|MCD272.35-1.68 (-0.61%) ▼|MDLZ65.69-0.88 (-1.31%) ▼|MDT100.61-0.11 (-0.11%) ▼|META596.22-20.16 (-3.27%) ▼|MMM178.47-2.58 (-1.43%) ▼|MO74.68-1.58 (-2.07%) ▼|MRK132.81-4.97 (-3.61%) ▼|MS174.98-6.19 (-3.42%) ▼|MSFT498.30-9.01 (-1.78%) ▼|MU690.44-14.83 (-2.10%) ▼|NEE83.79-0.99 (-1.17%) ▼|NFLX58.46-1.36 (-2.27%) ▼|NKE34.33-1.98 (-5.45%) ▼|NOW88.87-1.72 (-1.90%) ▼|NVDA145.98-4.98 (-3.30%) ▼|ORCL110.57-3.32 (-2.92%) ▼|PEP139.00-2.87 (-2.02%) ▼|PFE27.54-0.52 (-1.85%) ▼|PG167.85-2.44 (-1.43%) ▼|PLTR153.68-2.99 (-1.91%) ▼|PM186.43-6.30 (-3.27%) ▼|QCOM162.01+2.20 (+1.38%) ▲|RTX193.44-4.01 (-2.03%) ▼|SBUX104.47-4.64 (-4.25%) ▼|SCHW92.12-0.44 (-0.48%) ▼|SO93.29-1.12 (-1.19%) ▼|SPG225.22-6.16 (-2.66%) ▼|T21.85-0.10 (-0.46%) ▼|TMO688.75-3.99 (-0.58%) ▼|TMUS162.53-1.49 (-0.91%) ▼|TSLA374.41-9.31 (-2.43%) ▼|TXN285.75-6.68 (-2.28%) ▼|UBER65.60-3.16 (-4.60%) ▼|UNH330.48-19.43 (-5.55%) ▼|UNP290.63-10.27 (-3.41%) ▼|UPS109.11-1.92 (-1.73%) ▼|USB57.26-1.02 (-1.75%) ▼|V402.25-12.97 (-3.12%) ▼|VZ45.74-0.39 (-0.85%) ▼|WFC80.61-0.31 (-0.38%) ▼|WMT126.04-1.32 (-1.04%) ▼|XOM158.93-1.65 (-1.03%) ▼|
10.3 C
New York
Friday, November 20, 2026
Personal FinanceNvidia’s Decline Quantifies the Risks of Index Fund Concentration

Nvidia’s Decline Quantifies the Risks of Index Fund Concentration

Nvidia lost roughly 37% of its market value in six weeks — about $2 trillion. On 12 November, the day founder and chief executive Jensen Huang announced his resignation, the shares opened 13% down. The S&P 500 fell 0.35%.

Index fund investors, meanwhile, did nothing at all. And for all the warnings about index concentration, they had less to worry about than almost anyone.

A third of the value gone

The decline came in two stages, and the market reacted very differently to each. The first was a broad sell-off across AI stocks after the US midterm elections. On 5 November, Nvidia fell 9.3% and the S&P 500 dropped 4.4% — its worst day since April 2025. The second stage was specific to Nvidia. Huang resigned after reports of extramarital affairs, including one with a businesswoman whom US officials suspect of links to Chinese intelligence. China denies the allegation.

Then came the company’s results. They were excellent: quarterly revenue of $115.8 billion, more than double a year earlier, with a stronger sales forecast than analysts expected. The shares still fell. That combination — good news, falling price — is worth remembering the next time someone claims markets are purely a function of fundamentals. In the short run, they are a function of expectations, positioning and sentiment.

The warning about index fund concentration

For two years, index investors have been told that an S&P 500 fund is no longer properly diversified — that it is effectively a bet on a handful of tech giants, with Nvidia the largest of them. Not all of these warnings came from scaremongers. In March, Larry Swedroe, one of the most respected figures in evidence-based investing, cautioned that a single bad quarter at Nvidia, Apple or Microsoft could cost index investors more than they realise.

Nvidia has now had something far worse than a bad quarter. This was a genuine test of what one company’s collapse does to an index fund. The data provide a clear answer.

What the chart shows

Michael Batnick at The Compound has plotted every trading day of the past five years. Each dot shows how far Nvidia was below its peak on a given day, and how far SPY, a widely held S&P 500 fund, was below its own. Most dots sit along a line: when Nvidia was far below its high, so was the market. The dot for 12 November sits far from that line. Nvidia was 31% below its high; SPY was 2.3% below its own. Batnick noted nothing comparable had occurred in recent times. By 18 November, Nvidia was 37% below its record while the S&P 500 was roughly 6% below its own.

Why the index held up

The arithmetic is straightforward. An S&P 500 fund holds companies in proportion to market value. In August, Nvidia constituted about 8% of the index. A 37% fall in a holding of that size removes roughly 3% from the fund, all else equal. A sizeable loss, but nothing like the damage suffered by someone holding Nvidia directly.

A second mechanism worked automatically. As Nvidia’s price fell, its weight in the index shrank. On 16 November it slipped to third-largest US company for the first time in 18 months. No index fund sold a single share to make that happen; the fund simply reflects the change. Market-cap weighting applies discipline that individual investors rarely enforce on themselves — it sells what has fallen and buys what has risen, mechanically and without hesitation.

For UK investors in a global tracker, exposure is smaller still. Nvidia represented 5.25% of the MSCI World index at the end of October, slightly less than Apple. The same fall would take roughly 2% off such a fund.

Two experts, two opposite views

On a recent podcast, one guest argued Nvidia was effectively finished and that the market was under-reacting. The other pushed back: Nvidia remains dominant in AI, with long-term contracts and exceptional margins. By the end, they agreed the outcome was unknowable.

That is the relevant point. If experienced professionals cannot agree whether Nvidia’s best days are behind it, individual investors have no realistic prospect of doing better. The advantage of index investing is precisely that this knowledge is unnecessary.

The giants that fall

The pessimist’s concern has historical support. Michael Cembalest of J.P. Morgan Asset Management examined the ten companies that have held the top spot in the S&P 500 since 1960 — IBM, GE, Exxon, Cisco among them. Most subsequently lost much of their market share. He calls it the Icarus effect. Corporate dominance at scale has rarely persisted.

The risk that does matter

None of this makes index concentration harmless. It clarifies which concentration matters. Single-company collapse is what an index fund is designed to absorb. The larger risk is correlated risk: when several of the largest companies depend on the same narrative — here, AI — and fall together. We saw that on 5 November, and more of it in the following week as AI stocks kept sliding. The far bottom-left of Batnick’s chart marks 2022, the only period in five years when the S&P 500 closed more than 20% below its high, with Nvidia more than 60% below its own peak. No index fund could have avoided that.

What this means for you

An index fund does not protect you from a falling market. If a portfolio decline of a quarter would be intolerable, the rational response is to hold less in equities — not to select different equities. What an index fund does is prevent your financial future from depending on any single company, however dominant, or any single individual running it. Over the past six weeks, the fund absorbed company risk, as designed. It did not absorb theme risk, and it was never meant to.

The investors who bought Nvidia on that Thursday morning may yet be vindicated. Nobody knows. The structural advantage of the index investor is not needing to find out.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!

Please enter your name here
Captcha verification failed!
CAPTCHA user score failed. Please contact us!

Recent News